Public Sector Banks (PSU) vs. Private Banks: A Three-Year Performance Analysis
For the third consecutive year, public sector banks (PSU) have outperformed their private sector counterparts in India’s banking sector. This sustained trend can be attributed to several key factors, particularly the valuation metrics and changes in stock index performance. Let’s delve into the details of this comparative analysis.
Valuation Metrics – Price-to-Book Ratio (P/Bk)
One critical measure to assess the performance and attractiveness of banks is the Price-to-Book ratio (P/Bk). This metric compares the current market price of a bank’s shares to its book value per share. A higher P/Bk ratio suggests that investors are willing to pay more for a bank’s assets, which may indicate optimism about future growth and profitability.
12-Month Forward vs. 5-Year Average
To evaluate trends, it’s crucial to compare current P/Bk ratios to the five-year historical average. This helps us gauge whether banks are currently trading at premium or discount levels relative to their recent performance.
Top 3 PSU Banks
Among the top three public sector banks, we observe the following P/Bk ratios and their comparison to the five-year averages:
- State Bank of India (SBI):
- Current P/Bk: 1.4x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 1.2x
- Bank of Baroda (BoB):
- Current P/Bk: 1x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 0.6x
- Punjab National Bank (PNB):
- Current P/Bk: 0.8x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 0.4x
Top 3 Private Banks
Among the top three private sector banks, we observe the following P/Bk ratios and their comparison to the five-year averages:
- HDFC Bank:
- Current P/Bk: 2.6x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 3.2x
- ICICI Bank:
- Current P/Bk: 2.8x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 2.5x
- Kotak Mahindra Bank (KMB):
- Current P/Bk: 3.6x
- Five-year Average P/Bk: 4.7x
Change in Stock Index Performance – PSU vs. Private
Another significant aspect to consider is how the stock indices of PSU and private banks have evolved over the years. The percentage change in the index values provides insights into overall market sentiment and investor confidence.
Here’s the year-wise comparison of stock index performance:
| Year | PSU Banks (% Change) | Private Banks (% Change) |
| 2021 | 44% | 5% |
| 2022 | 71% | 21% |
| 2023 | 14% | 9% |
The data clearly shows that PSU banks have consistently outperformed private banks over this three-year period, not only in terms of valuation metrics but also in terms of stock index performance.
In summary, PSU banks have demonstrated their resilience and attractiveness to investors by consistently delivering strong performance, reflected in their P/Bk ratios and stock index growth. This trend suggests that PSU banks have successfully navigated challenges and gained the confidence of the market. However, it’s essential to keep monitoring these trends to assess the sustainability of this performance over the long term.
Top of Form